Social Media Quality VS Quantity

Why Your Content Needs Social Media Targeting

Social Media Quality vs QuantityBrand message repetition has long been a key to advertising success.

The rule of thumb is that your target audience must see your message 5 to 7 times before they believe it.

To achieve this objective, today’s marketers must distribute their content on social media because it’s where their prospects spend their time, over an hour a day!!!

Yet with the flood of content hitting your target audience on social media your message’s repetition can feel like a hammer that just keeps banging.

This shouldn’t come as a surprise. Only 38% of marketers rate their content as effective. Even more amazing, 19% of marketers rate their content as not effective according to Content Marketing Institute and MarketingProfs’ 2015 B2B research.2015_B2B_Research-Content Effectiveness-CMI

Social media quality vs quantitySocial Media Quality vs Quantity

While brand-generated content distributed across social media continues to increase, it yields the lowest engagement to-date according to Track Maven analysis for 2013 and 2014.

  • Brand-generated content by channel increased 78%.
  • Interactions per post per 1,000 followers decreased 60%.

Bottom line: More content distributed across more social media platforms doesn’t translate to greater consumption or interaction. As a result, the increased content creation and distribution costs don’t help your business.Social Media Quality vs Quantity

SOcial Media Quality vs QuantitySocial media quantity can become TOO much brand communication. Remember participants use social media primarily to communicate with family and friends.

While you need a variety of different social media platforms to reach your maximum target audience, avoid increasing your social media quantity to the point where people are blind to it.

To appreciate the power of quality social media content, Pottery Barn posted 60 Pins in October, 2014 that yielded 343 interactions per Pin on average; over 3 times their average engagement in July. Pottery Barn-Social Media Quality tracked by Track Maven-1

YET, social media quality needs to reach a broad enough audience to drive traffic and ultimately sales. Recently, social media passed search in terms of driving more traffic to websites. This makes social media a key element for content marketing distribution. Maximize social sharing - Shareaholic chart

To understand how to balance social media quality vs quantity, let’s examine best, average and lowest social media engagement.

1. Best social media engagement

The best social media engagement according to Track Maven was on Instagram and Facebook:

  • 49% of Instagram photos and 60% of Instagram videos receive 250+ interactions. (Note: We predicted video would be strong in 2015!) By contrast, 10% of Instagram photos and 6% of Instagram videos receive 10 or fewer interactions. (Here’s more data on Instagram.) Instagram - TrackMaven
  • 36% of Facebook content receives 250+ interactions. Of note, Facebook, sponsored content accounted for the vast majority of posts with 250+ interactions.

NOTE: Track Maven’s data did NOT include YouTube. This matters. YouTube is the social media platform most strongly associated with sales results according to AOL data. YouTube is the #2 search engine. Global Web Index ranked it in the Top 4 social networks globally.

Convertro_SocialMedia_report 2014-2

Actionable Marketing Tactics:

• Know your customer.

Create a marketing persona to understand your prospects’ needs. Put yourself in your customers’ shoes. Appreciate where and how they participate on social media. Here’s the data on 2015 Social Media Behavior (It includes more charts like this one.)Social Media Behavior in 2015- Network size chart

• Target your content to meet your audience’s specific needs.

Provide the information they actively seek, before you even know they are in market for your goods and services. 64% of shoppers surveyed researched products and retailers online prior to their store visit. 

This means the 5 basic content types: give them complete product information, answer customer questions, show customers how to use your products, help customers style your products, and share customer ratings and reviews. 

BTW: Online ratings and reviews influenced 48% of shoppers, up 45% from 2012 based on Baynote research. To help you, here’s more information regarding social media ratings and reviews.

• Use visual content on social media to attract attention and engage your audience.

People are visual beings. Improve your content’s ability to be seen with an image.

• Support your content distribution with paid advertising.

This is particularly important on Facebook where organic reach has declined and where you can hyper-target your advertising. (Here are 5 Key Facebook tactics for 2015 complete with charts.)

2. Average social media engagement

Owned social media engagement, namely blogs, performed in the middle according to Track Maven. No surprise since as a longer form of content, blogs support search optimization. They provide entryways to your offering. Also, blog owners have moved away from comments as an indictor of blog success.

  • 43% of professionally marketed blog posts receive less than 10 interactions.
  • 23% of brand-generated blog posts receive NO interactions.

Actionable Marketing Tactics:

• Broaden your content distribution beyond owned platforms to reach new prospects.

Use a combination of owned, social media and other third party platforms to reach a bigger potential audience.

• Optimize your content to be search friendly.

This provides other entries to your content that aren’t measured by this data.

3. Lowest social media engagement

The lowest social media engagement according to TrackMaven occurred on Twitter.

  • 73% of tweets receive 10 or less interactions.

This should be no surprise since the half-life of a tweet is VERY SHORT.

Unless participants are targeting your thought leaders or brand, the chances are small that they’ll see your tweet. It’s why Guy Kawasaki recommends tweeting every 8 hours. 

Actionable Marketing Tactics:

• Provide sufficient information to engage your key prospects.

By design, tweets are a maximum of 140 characters. Improve engagement with photographs. (Here are 16 ridiculously easy ways to increase retweets.)

• Target your social media distribution to maximize results.

Optimize your content based on the social media platform where you’re placing it. Also, select social media platforms based on your target audience’s preferences.

• Include a call-to-action.

Encourage your audience to take the next step in the process. Links can be effective means to get participants to your website or landing page.


The bottom line for marketers is to balance your social media quality with quantity.

To maximize your social media results, continue to test new types of information, presentation and social media platforms.

Then track your social media results to determine what works best for your business.

Which do you think is better: social media quality or quantity? Why do you think so? 

Happy Marketing,
Heidi Cohen



Photo Credit: #55H via

Tags , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Social Media Quality VS Quantity