Gated Content VS Ungated Content

Maximize Gated Content Results: What You Need To Know

Gated Content VS Ungated ContentHow does the form guarding your precious gated content look to your visitors?

Does your gated content whisper velvet rope entry for special guests or does it scream go away unless you’re willing to hand over your data?

Tourists line up and pay to enter Livraria Lello in Porto, Portugal to soak up the wood carved interior that inspired J.K. Rowling. To feel the Harry Potter magic, they don’t think twice about the exchange.

Lello Bookshop, Porto, PortugalMy Lello visit got me thinking about how marketers put gates in front of their content.

We seek visitors’ information so we can convert them into qualified sales leads. But do we stop to consider how our visitors feel after the exchange?

Lello’s visitors leave feeling happy and transformed. They’ve photos they treasure and share across social media.

How do your visitors feel your gated content experience?

This article will help you improve your gated content experience to reach your content marketing objectives.

Gated content defined

Gated content is high-value information visitors want and need that resides behind a form. To access the content, users must exchange their personal data by answering the form’s questions. It’s part of your overall content marketing strategy.


Why gate content?

While content often appears to be free, advertising from businesses interested in the audience supports it.

Content, however, isn’t innately free. As a business you’ve invested resources to create and distribute it.

So it seems logical from a business perspective that it should be part of a prospect transaction. Yet the problem is your target audience expects you to provide the content for free.

Marketing Dilemma:

How to get your content to break through, get seen, and yield sales qualified leads?


Gated Content VS Ungated Content Examples

Here are the 5 major types of gated and ungated content. Use them as a guide when making your decisions.

But if you feel strongly about changing your approach for a specific type of content, test it.

Gated content examples include:

  • Newsletters
  • Books/excerpts
  • Research/white papers
  • Webinars/events/video replays
  • Software tools

Ungated content examples include:

  • Blog posts
  • Articles, especially news and curation
  • Social media content
  • Infographics
  • Older newsletters

Gated Content VS Ungated Content

Gated Content VS Ungated Content Advantages and Disadvantages

The tradeoffs between gated content and ungated content boil down to your marketing goals: Do you need traffic and reach or qualified sales leads?

Gated Content Advantages:

  • Yields more respondent information. Know your audience better.
  • Increases content value perception. If you just give it away, it can’t be worthwhile.
  • Improves sales conversions. Qualify prospects that are interested in your products. You can start with warm leads.


Gated Content Disadvantages:

  • Reduces audience size since people don’t want to share their information.
  • Hinders search and amplification results since content isn’t searched and less likely to get links. (BTW, as Rand Fishkin points out it’s easy to get around your gating for links.)
  • Yields poor data. I’m surprised more marketers don’t assess this problem. Personally, I’m willing to exchange my information for quality content or with businesses I know. But generally, if I’m seeking information, I’ll do whatever is needed.


Ungated Content Advantages:

  • Increases traffic and visibility while making your content sharable via social and email.
  • Provides search benefits since it’s not behind a form. This also applies to links.
  • Build trust with prospects. Removes roadblocks to visitor action.


Ungated Content Disadvantages:

  • Makes conversion difficult since you can’t directly continue to provide tailored content. (BTW, Larry Kim believes it’s possible to remarket visitors based on their past activity on your website, blog and some social media sites.)
  • Looses potential data from prospects and referrals.
  • Requires another way to encourage prospects to raise their hands.


Moz’s Rand Fishkin puts it best:

“If audience size, reach, and future marketing benefits are greater than detailed leads, then go [with] open access. If the reverse is true, if detailed leads are more valuable, then go with a gated model.” (Editor’s note: We reduced Fishkin’s quote to the essence.)

Gated Content Alternatives - Via Moz

But your choice to gate isn’t all or nothing as Fishkin points out. A less followed option is to semi-gate or add-on gating. This allows visitors to access part of your high value content while providing some information.


Gated Content VS Ungated Content Research

B2B marketers gate 80% of high-value content marketing assets behind lead generation forms (Starfleet Media’s 2014 B2B Content Marketing and Lead Generation Research). This proportion seems high to me since you need sufficient content to attract prospects and build trust.

B2B Marketers Gate 80% of Content – Starfleet Research Chart


Drift ungated all of their content in April 2016. Specifically, they removed forms except for a lonely email subscribe button.

By doing so, they drove greater leads. While this appears to make the case for ungated content, it understates the reality.

Drift’s software provides an ever-present messaging functionality. Visitors see a friendly face ready to answer questions. This transforms every page into a lead generator.

Drift’s Gated Content Alternative

As a result, Drift’s approach is more akin to an add-on gating approach that answers customer questions on the spot without delayed sales follow up.


5 Questions to Answer Before Gating Content

Before gating content, assess whether your content should be gated. Most importantly ask: Have you earned the right to ask prospects for their personal information? 

1. What is your gated content objective and is it related to your content mission and strategy?

Marketing tradeoff for gated content: Traffic numbers versus qualified leads. Related to this challenge is the issue of numbers. Only a small proportion of visitors will complete forms. Without sufficient traffic you won’t hit your lead quota.

Therefore assess at what point in their purchase decision do prospects need this information? Ideally, put gated content between the product consideration and decision phases. This way you can answer remaining questions and close the sale.

2. How available is your gated content?

Is the information hard to find or organize (i.e. Is it worth an information exchange to your prospect?) This is a major reason to gate research.

Determine if others give this information away for free. At a minimum, check competitors’ content offering.

Does your audience perceive the information is high-value? This means formatting, presentation and ease of content consumption.

3. Have you earned the right to ask for visitors’ information?

Do you have enough supporting ungated content to attract people who are so interested they’ll exchange their data? Use the hub and spoke approach to provide smaller chunks of related information building trust with prospects so they’ll trade their personal information. Amplify your ungated content distribution.

4. How will you use the information you collect?

Each piece of information you request diminishes the number of people who complete your form. Further, less than a 100% of those conversions will ultimately buy. Consider the following:

  • What action do I want my prospects to take next?
  • Will our sales team be able and willing to use the information generated in a timely manner?
  • How many potential customers will I loose because they won’t fill out the form?

What is the minimum amount information you need to collect? Before you decide, know how you will use each element of data. Assess what information you currently collect from prospects and how you use it. Can you ask for visitor data in a tiered approach to minimize your upfront request?  

What is the quality of the information you receive? While many people will fill out forms honestly, know what proportion of data is usable.

5. How will you test the effectiveness of gating your content?

Don’t assume your content should be gated. Test gating versus ungated content to prove it yields the results you expect. This isn’t seat of your pants marketing.


How To Create Gated Content

1. Map your content to your buyer’s journey

Meet your audience’s specific needs. There’s no one path to purchase. Organize your information in terms of awareness, consideration and decision. Ideally gate content that helps prospects move from consideration to purchase.

2. Create related ungated content to attract prospects to gated content

Develop supporting content to get visitors wanting more, deeper information. Warm your prospects by using useful information.

Distribute ungated content broadly to attract interested readers.

3. Tailor gated content landing page

Continue to qualify prospects and keep them on track with your landing page.

Highlight their painpoints, set expectations for your content and show benefits of the gated information to remove doubts and motivate them to act. 

4. Include a thank you page

Use a thank you page to communicate to prospects that their information has been collected and to direct them to the next steps.

Set or reinforce expectations for your content. Outline next steps. Don’t assume readers will know what you want them to do next.

If you don’t allow downloads directly from your thank you page, explain this.

Keep your branding and voice consistent.

5. Send follow up email

Even if you allow prospects to download the information directly from your thank you page, send them another link to it.

Also have a series of emails in place to continue to warm prospects. Provide future steps and engagement.


Gated content vs ungated content conclusion

Gating content isn’t an all or nothing activity.

The key to your decision is to continually test whether your forms are yielding quality results and whether you’re able to use them.

Don’t allow leads to wallow too long without communications. It dilutes their interest in your business.

Have a series of useful content in place to automatically drip out to your new leads.

Where possible include a question to get them engaged where your sales team can respond quickly.

You can reveal some of your content to entice potential readers to want more. You can offer related content or gate the remainder of the content.

Alternatively, you can provide other ways to capture prospects such as content upgrades.

Happy Marketing,
Heidi Cohen

Heidi CohenHeidi Cohen is the President of Riverside Marketing Strategies.
You can find Heidi on Google+, Facebook and Twitter.


Creator Economy Expo
May 5th - 7th in Cleveland, Ohio

Join bloggers, podcasters, authors, newsletter writers, speakers, coaches and consultants, freelancers, and YouTubers at THE learning and networking event for content entrepreneurs.

Read our interview with Joe Pulizzi, Content, Inc. – Revised Edition

Photo Credit: CC Zero

Tags , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Gated Content VS Ungated Content