Social Media and Branding: Is It Worth The Money?

How to Align Your Social Media and Marketing Budget

While over 90% of brands use some form of social media, they don’t put their marketing muscle behind their social media execution. Recent research by Technorati raises questions about the disconnect between being on social media and using it as an effective marketing conduit.

According to Technorati Media’s 2013 Digital Influence Report, 41% of marketers spend $10 million or less on digital media. To put this in perspective, the media cost for a single 2013 Super Bowl ad was between $3.7 million and $3.8 million.  

The lion’s share of this digital marketing spend or two-fifths is allocated to display advertising, One in eight ads across the web is socially enabled according to comScore. While not specifically social media, these ads encourage customers to engage by “Liking” or “Following” them on social media platforms. The benefit of this consumer activity is that it provides earned media impressions.

Of this digital advertising pie, social media advertising comprises only 10% of total ad budget. Of that social budget, more than half goes to Facebook while YouTube and Twitter together comprise about a quarter of the budget. (Not included in these numbers is video production that accounts for 14% of the total digital spend.) 

While Facebook, Twitter and YouTube are high on marketers’ lists, based on Technorati’s research, only a third use blogs and about a quarter use Google+.  Given the size and time spent on the big three, it makes sense that marketers include them in their social media plans. That said, the fact that blogs and Google+ also help support search makes it surprising that these two social media options aren’t used more broadly. (Here are fourteen more charts on social media and brands.)

In a recent interview on Bloomberg Radio, Scott Monty head of social media at Ford Motor Company, said that they used different social media platforms to achieve different goals.

What’s missing from this social media equation?

These numbers only account for paid social media advertising. While social media advertising can be important as a tool to support your other social media efforts, it’s insufficient by itself.

In fact, GM dropped Facebook advertising from their marketing mix prior to the Facebook IPO while they kept their Facebook page. Unlike traditional media where the media cost tends to be significantly higher than the advertisement, on social media, the cost of staff engagement and related content are higher than the media expense.

What is important for social media marketing that these numbers don’t take into account are the fully loaded cost for staff (marketing, sales, PR and customer service), related creative (including consultants and agencies), content marketing, social media monitoring and technology to maintain a social media presence. (BTW, here’s what ten social media experts say about social media metrics.)

An example of how social media marketing can be effective without related advertising (traditional or social media based) was Oreo who made a great splash or should I say dunk at the Super Bowl. By having it’s social advertising firm and marketers watching the game together in real time, they were able to take advantage of the stadium blackout with a clever tweet that earned lots of attention in the marketing press after the game.

Oreo Super Bowl Photo Tweet

By contrast, Poland Spring, owned by global marketing giant Nestle, blew a great social media opportunity by not responding or taking action when Senator Marco Rubio reached for a bottle of their water during his State of the Union response. Without advertising, Poland Spring should have commented or communicated via social media; alternatively, they could have sent Rubio a case of water.  Instead Rubio carried his own bottle of Poland Spring with him during his post-speech press interviews the next morning. 

What these social brands do track is earned media across a variety of metrics. 55% of brands do so according to Technorati’s findings. Yet, their metrics tend to only assess earned media impressions that lead to further social media activity. There’s no connection between social media generated brand impact and purchase related actions. 

This research underscores the need for brand marketers to go beyond considering social media in the traditional sense of being a media entity. It’s more than a place to post and distribute promotional messages. Social media requires being social. To this end, brands must engage with their prospects, customers and fans as humans and understand why they’re on social media.

What has your brand experience been on social media?

Happy Marketing,
Heidi Cohen


Heidi CohenHeidi Cohen is the President of Riverside Marketing Strategies. You can find Heidi on , Facebook and .

For those of you in Raleigh, NC, please join me for Internet Summit November 11th through 13th. Internet Summit
Use the code HEIDI50 to save $50 OFF any pass level.

Even though Content Marketing World is finished until next September, you can still get all the content from 2014's exciting conference. The CMWorld On Demand package includes: Audio and video from the 2014 keynote sessions, audio and PowerPoint presentations of all the breakout sessions, over 40 audio sessions from the leading B2B and B2C brands, as well as keynote video performances.

CMWonDemand

Free Webcast!

Return on Authenticity:
Making Effective Storytelling and Content Performance Align

Return on Authenticity: Making Effective Storytelling and Content Performance AlignJoin the discussion on Wednesday, October 29, 2014 at 10:00 AM PT/ 1:00 PM ET with Nancy Slavin, SVP of Marketing, Macy's Merchandising Group, and Dan Kimball, CMO, Thismoment.

According to research by Nielsen, 70 percent of global consumers trust online consumer reviews and rate reviews as the second most trusted form of advertising. And according to BazaarVoice, when it comes to trust, marketers may as well eliminate their own brand websites as a fountain of customer trust as only 16 percent of US consumers said they trust the content on a brand's website compared to the 51 percent who trust content generated by other users.

Today's digital currency is arguably authenticity, and what attracts customers - especially the digitally dependent, savvy millennial - is not just content. It is the delivery of authentic, unvarnished content from their peers.

Join the CMO Council on Wednesday, October 29, at 10am PST/ 1pm EST for a one-hour webcast that will invite industry experts in content marketing and user-generated content who are effectively leveraging authentic storytelling as part of their content marketing strategies. We will also feature an interactive Q&A session at the conclusion of the speaker presentations.

Register for this Free Webcast today!


 

 

Related Articles

Photo Credit: http://www.flickr.com/photos/hamed/463879686/

 

Tags , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • http://akplay.tumblr.com kaznaaa

    Heidi,

    Great article. I can provide feedback for the Poland Spring part. Poland Spring is owned by Nestle. Poland Spring is available in Florida as gallon jugs, home/office delivery only. I know this because I moved from NJ to FL and had to switch water. I had to switch to Zephyrhills, which is a locally-sourced water owned by Nestle, sold in all sorts of shapes and sizes to Florida residents. I can think that Nestle/Poland Spring did not advertise further, or shout out, because they did not or cannot afford to have an uproar or a request from Floridians as to why Poland Spring is not sold in Florida (in bottles).

    That’s all!